Fast Forward Accounting Solutions
  • Home
  • Services
    • CFO and Controller Services
    • Interim and Project Staffing
    • QuickBooks Support
    • Audit Preparation
    • Income Tax Preparation
    • Bookkeeping & Payroll
  • Our Team
  • Resources
  • Accounting News
    • Budgeting
    • Business
    • Payroll
    • Personal
    • Tax Planning
  • Contact Us
  • Search
  • Menu Menu

Retirees Often Make This Major Social Security Mistake

April 23, 2018

Most people are aware of the advice “delay your Social Security until age 70.”

Many reject it because they created an Excel spreadsheet that seems to contradict it, or they think they won’t live long enough to make it pay off, or because they just can’t stand working past age 65 (or 66 or 67). In addition, they look at the idea of putting off taking Social Security by funding their living expenses with withdrawals from their IRAs or 401(k)s with disdain, because those accounts are 100% taxable upon receipt and they hate “giving money to Uncle Sam.”

Unfortunately, for many people, the decision to start Social Security before age 70 and delay withdrawing money from a traditional IRA until age 70½, when required minimum distributions (RMDs) begin, is completely backward.

Let’s break this down into three main points:

1. You’re Giving Up On A Higher Social Security Benefit

Once you reach your full retirement age, your monthly Social Security check gets 8% larger for every year you delay taking benefits through age 70 (technically, it’s 2/3% per month). Mathematically, the “crossover point” is about 12 years.

For example, suppose at full retirement age (which is 67 if you were born in 1960 or later) your Social Security check is $2,000 per month (or $24,000 per year). At age 70, that check would be $2,480 per month ($29,760 per year). By waiting until age 70 to start taking benefits, by the time you reach age 83 you would have been paid a total of $386,880, compared with the $384,000 you would have gotten if you had started at age 67, even though you got income for three extra years. The average life expectancy of a 67-year-old is at least 85, and growing, so any year you live past age 83 is money in your pocket.

Basically, the advice to delay Social Security is correct.

2. You Still Have To Pay Taxes On Your Tax-Deferred Accounts No Matter What

Your traditional IRA, 401(k), 403(b), etc., is 100% taxable to you or your heirs, and at some point it will be fully liquidated to you or them. Putting off taking withdrawals from it does not change those facts. You get no tax benefit by delaying.

3. It’s Not How Much Money You Make That Counts, But How Much You Keep

Social Security income is never more than 85% taxable, but it could be 0% taxable. The taxed amount is determined by an 18-step calculation in the return instructions for Form 1040. Essentially, the process tells you to take half of your Social Security benefit, add that to all your “other income” and then perform a series of calculations to determine how much of your Social Security (between 0% and 85%) is taxable.

In other words, the bigger your Social Security check and the less “other income” you have (for the same total income), the less your adjusted gross income and the less tax you will pay.

Putting This Strategy To Work: One Couple’s Story

The realization of these three points offers insight into sound retirement planning: If you plan to retire before age 70, consider delaying your Social Security until age 70 and living off your retirement accounts from your retirement date until then.

For example, Bob and Mary, both age 65, have just retired. Together, they receive pensions of $1,500 per month and are eligible (at age 65) for combined Social Security benefits of $3,500 per month ($42,000 per year). They need $5,000 per month for their living expenses. They also have 401(k)s worth $300,000.

Succumbing to “conventional wisdom” myths, Bob and Mary start their Social Security at age 65, justifying that in combination with their pensions, they’ll get the $5,000 per month they need. Over the next five years, their 401(k)s grow at 5% per year. Five years later, they are worth $382,884 with a first year RMD of $13,306. Their gross annual income is $73,306, of which only $13,360 of their Social Security is taxable. Their adjusted gross (taxable) income is $44,366. Bob and Mary are happy.

Conversely, if they delayed their Social Security and instead withdrew $3,500 per month from their 401(k)s until age 70, at that time their 401(k)s would have been depleted to under $140,000 and they would generate a first year RMD of $6,371. But, by waiting, their Social Security has grown by 8% per year for five years and now pays $58,800 per year of which only $14,305 is taxable. Their gross income has increased to $83,171 and their adjusted gross (taxable) income has dropped to $38,676. In other words, while their total income increased by $9,865, their taxable income fell by $5,690. That’s a net improvement of $15,555, and this advantage will continue for the rest of their lives.

Further, whoever dies first, the survivor will get the larger of the two Social Security checks, either of which is now a lot larger by having waited. This is important, because the surviving spouse’s standard deduction just got reduced by half and having more 100% taxable income from 401(k)s (vs. Social Security) may serve to increase the total income tax load. If Bob and Mary are of different ages, whoever passes first, the survivor gets to assume the other’s 401(k) and take RMDs on that account based on the age of the younger spouse.

Finally, if Bob and Mary have any non-IRA type investments, they can grow those without spending them down for routine income. If an emergency arises, they can access that money at a lower tax rate (long-term capital gain) and if they don’t need the money, when they pass that money transfers to their kids with a Step-up in Income Tax Basis, meaning their kids will owe less income tax. That’s not the case with IRAs.

The value of delaying Social Security until age 70 is far more than just getting “more money per month.” There are tax advantages, surviving spouse advantages, even inheritance advantages when the entire portfolio and estate are considered as a whole. However, there are times and circumstances when this advice is not suitable, and this is the reason for seeking professional financial guidance before implementing decisions about when to start Social Security and when to start withdrawing from your IRA, 401(k), etc.

 

Source: Nasdaq

Tags: 401(k), IRAs, retirement, social security benefit, tax-deferred account, taxable income
Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share by Mail
0 0 ADMIN https://dev.fastforwardaccounting.net/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Fast-Forward-Accounting-Solutions-Logo-Web.png ADMIN2018-04-23 07:35:292018-04-23 07:35:29Retirees Often Make This Major Social Security Mistake
You might also like
When To Worry If Your Tax Refund Is Delayed
Fed Rate Hike: 7 Questions (And Answers)
44% Of Savers In Their 20s And 30s Want To Retire By 60, But Few Are On Track—See How You Stack Up
Can’t Pay Or File Your Taxes By April 15? Here’s What Happens If You Missed Monday’s Deadline
Tax Credits vs. Tax Deductions
8 Financial Tips for Women

What Can We Help You Find?

Recent Posts

  • New IRS Tax Pro Account Tools Make Business Tax Payments EasierNovember 10, 2026 - 2:13 am

    The IRS now allows authorized tax professionals to make certain federal tax payments on behalf of business clients, giving small-business owners another reason to work closely with their accountant throughout the year.

  • Self-Employed? New HSA Rules Could Help Lower Your TaxesNovember 2, 2026 - 9:37 pm

    If you buy your own health insurance, a change to the Health Savings Account rules could give you a new opportunity to reduce your taxable income while setting aside money for healthcare expenses.

  • Beware Of Ghost Tax Preparers: Five Warning Signs You Shouldn’t IgnoreOctober 26, 2026 - 3:12 pm

    Suspected “ghost preparers” were tied to nearly $179 million in potentially fraudulent tax refunds. Here are five warning signs to watch for before trusting someone with your return.

  • You Don’t Have To Itemize To Deduct Charitable Donations In 2026October 19, 2026 - 2:40 pm

    Beginning in 2026, taxpayers who take the standard deduction may deduct up to $1,000—or $2,000 for married couples filing jointly—in qualifying charitable cash contributions.

  • Bought A New Car? You May Be Able To Deduct The Loan InterestOctober 12, 2026 - 8:31 pm

    A new federal tax deduction could allow eligible taxpayers to deduct up to $10,000 a year in interest paid on qualifying new-vehicle loans. But not every car or buyer qualifies.

  • New Education Freedom Tax Credit Begins In 2027: What Taxpayers Should KnowOctober 5, 2026 - 7:13 pm

    A new federal tax credit beginning in 2027 could provide taxpayers with up to $1,700—or $3,400 for married couples filing jointly—for qualifying contributions to scholarship organizations.

  • Paid To Care For A Family Member? Here’s What the IRS Says About TaxesSeptember 28, 2026 - 5:01 pm

    The IRS recently reminded taxpayers that family caregivers who are paid for their services may have income-reporting requirements, and the tax treatment can depend on whether the caregiver is considered an employee or is providing caregiving services as a business.

  • Received An IRS CP53E Notice? Here’s What It MeansSeptember 21, 2026 - 4:18 pm

    Millions of taxpayers received unfamiliar IRS CP53E notices during the 2026 filing season. Here’s what the notice means, why it was sent and what to do if you receive one.

FAST FORWARD ACCOUNTING SOLUTIONS

A client focused accounting firm that serves business throughout South Florida.

Latest Projects

  • Project 6 – Living Room DesignOctober 30, 2015 - 5:09 pm
  • Project 5 – More InteriorOctober 30, 2015 - 5:07 pm
  • Project 4 – Office TowerOctober 21, 2015 - 3:47 pm

Contact Us

Fast Forward Accounting Solutions, P.A.
2834 University Drive
Coral Springs, Florida 33065
954.821.5378

Copyright © 2023 Fast Forward Accounting Solutions | Site Designed By CRE-sources, Inc.
Less Than 3 Percent Of Americans Can Pass This Six-Question Money QuizFinancial Advisor Suze Orman: “Here’s What You Should Do With Your Tax...
Scroll to top